The Official Website of Legendary Direct Mail Copywriter, Josh C. Manheimer
The Official Website of Legendary Direct Mail Copywriter, Josh C. Manheimer

The Official Website of Powerhouse Direct Response Copywriter and Performance Creative Strategist, Josh C. Manheimer

I’m the guy who writes the thing that drives people crazy for your stuff.

Old School Direct Mail Copywriter featured in MILLION DOLLAR MAILINGS, WHO'S MAILING WHAT, INSIDE DIRECT MAIL, and THE WORLD'S GREATEST DIRECT MAIL SALES LETTERS.

I tag team with growth marketers … founders … agencies … artists … mad scientists … and help articulate what makes your feverish vision unique. Clearly and compellingly. So folks stop. Nod their heads. And shout, “Count me in.”

My name is Josh Manheimer and I sail in the vast sea of Performance Marketing, often doubling response rates for my clients with compelling, hand-crafted copy that motivates people to take action.

I can work alone. For you. With you. One on one. (No agency bloat.)

Or I can climb onto your bus. Share my tuna sandwich. And my expertise. (Other creative types usually like having me around.)

“Dear Mr. Manheimer, I hardly ever write to people I don’t know on the Internet, but had to after I stumbled across your website and was blown away by control samples you put up… …and even more blown away by the PR pitches you gave out for FREE.  As a fresh copywriter - you sir, are a breath of fresh air in a world of self-proclaimed Internet copywriting “gurus” and an inspiration for someone who wants to hone their craft.“
--Nathaniel (Australia)

J.C. Manheimer #1 Old School

Often I'm asked by savvy growth marketers to go up against the best performance-driven copywriters in the world -- and run circles around them.

Perhaps you’ve heard of these prestigious brands?

Their marketing teams learned long ago that testing fresh creative by the top direct response copywriters in the country is the fastest engine for growth.

 

Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients
Clients

"Your direct mail package indexed 340!
Unbelievable! "

-Kim Souza, Marketing Manager, Affinity Group

 

"We were astonished when your direct mail package pulled 72% better. I had not thought such an increase was possible."

Rob Dubin, Publisher, Sailing Quarterly

"Not sure if anyone's mailing these days. And I'm really not sure anyone's posting 10% response rates. Anyone, that is, but MaryJanesFarm!"

G.K., Belvoir Media Group

"Your package beat our launch package by almost 50% on a net response basis.This is a phenomenal response!"

Jackie Prince, Doubletake


I’ve had an 11-year-control for NFPA. A 10-year control for Writer’s Digest. An 8-year control for Southern Living. A 5-year control for The NY Review of Books.

"I've never written a letter to a direct mail copywriter before. But your subscription package for Writer's Digest was super."
Bob Bly
Author
The Copywriter's Handbook

 

"I am NOT the greatest storytelling copywriter in America. That title belongs to ... Josh Manheimer.This guy doesn’t just beat controls, he bludgeons them to death with 100%, 200%, even 300% victories."

Richard Armstrong, A-List Copywriter

 

"I bought John Carlton's Kiss Ass Copywriting course way back in 2003 for $1,495. I bought AWAI's course in 2005 for $495.
I then bought AWAI's Master Program for $795. bought Clayton Makepeace's Quick Start Copywriting course for $795 (now it's $1,295.  I went to the Titians of Direct Response event several years ago, and spent a small fortune to be there ... and the DVD's to the event still sell for $2,000 even today. I was Dan Kennedy's NO BS Adviser to Birmingham, AL ... which cost me $14,000. None of this includes every possible copywriting resource I have on hand, both analog and digital. My point, Josh, is that of all the resources I have on hand ... dude ... I constantly find myself bypassing all of them for your work. That, in my mind, is pretty remarkable."
—Aaron C., Veteran Conversion Copywriter

"A 14% response is perfectly incredible!"

F&W Publishing

"Just wanted to let you guys know that your package killed the control by more than 50%! Nice job."

Dean Lage
Belvoir Media Group

"Cash orders is 84%. That's fairly phenomenal, Josh."

Colleen Cannon
Promotion Directo

"JOSH: 10.55% Congratulations!

Ellen de Lathouder
Circulation Director
Southern Progress

Master the Art of Written Persuasion

Welcome to Josh's

DMU

Direct Mail University

Need inspiration? Thumb through my legendary direct mail campaigns and learn how I beat controls.

"The improvement in p(1) net subs was a whopping 45%! "

Chris Salem
Circulation Director
Horticulture

"Josh, I've used your letter with our current donors and...
this is the best response rate we've received!"

Rob Benn-Frenette
Executive Director
BullyingCanada

Why adding a proven, old school, performance copywriter to your stable of talent can really boost your response rates today.

Direct mail and long-form conversion copy work because they grab attention by creating a one-to-one relationship with your tribe.

 

Unlike a banner ad or social scroll, a sales letter--when crafted correctly--forces a personal, linear experience. The reader slows down, allowing the copywriter to frame the problem, build belief, anticipate objections, introduce proof, and present the offer in a compelling way.

 

That sequence drives response.

 

No matter whether you are selling insurance, health, financial services, membership, enthusiast markets — response depends on clarity, credibility, and a great offer. 

 

Long-form copy gives you the chance to weave together the threads so they conspire (and create the magic) that triggers action.

 

Interestingly, a copywriter's skills transfer easily from old school direct mail to new school Instagram carousels.  It's the same old Art of Persuasion, repackaged for today's attention span -- from Stone Tablet to Apple iPhone.

Let's just say I'm pretty good at my day job. You'll find my work featured in MILLION DOLLAR MAILINGS, WHO'S MAILING WHAT, INSIDE DIRECT MAIL, and THE WORLD'S GREATEST DIRECT MAIL SALES LETTERS (four times). 

I've created the most successful direct mail campaign in the history of Rodale Press.  The most successful in the history of the Meredith Corporation.  And huge, historical winners for The Danbury Mint and Time-Life (OxMoor House).

I've had an 11-year control for THE NATIONAL FIRE PROTECTION ASSOCIATION.  A ten-year control for WRITER'S DIGEST.  An eight-year control for SOUTHERN LIVING. And a five-year control for THE NY REVIEW OF BOOKS. 

My control for THE ASIAN WALL STREET JOURNAL quadrupled response and -- it was written in Chinese! 

My sales letter for CONSUMER REPORTS rolled out to 40 million people, and my winning effort for BETTER HOMES AND GARDENS would mail to every household in the country. 

It's not unusual for me to get love letters like this from my professional colleagues:

If you want to witness brilliance, go to Josh's website and read every single word of every single page. Then save the pages to your computer and repeat the exercise again next week. Then the week after. Continue doing this week after week. In just a few months of this routine, you'll have gained more copywriting insight than sitting down with Gene Schwartz himself. That Josh dude is a monster. And there's a ton you can pick up from his samples on his website.  —K.G. (Facebook)

 

Because a fresh perspective from a proven, old school, direct response copywriter can energize your folks with fresh ideas ... offer new ways of presenting old features and benefits ... supply innovative nuances to how you phrase your offer and guarantee ... create captivating voices (demanding to be heard) who really speak to your audience ...

... which all conspire to help widen the columns on your spreadsheets with big response breakthroughs.

I've  gone up against the best copywriters in the world—and beaten them. How?

By getting your audience to nod their heads in agreement and trust what you have to say. By tapping into their desires, their fears, and their sense of urgency to drive action now. By crafting great stories to capture attention.  Powerful features and benefits to trigger their engagement.  Iron-clad guarantees to reassure those who are hesitant.  Compelling offers to motivate qualified buyers to say, “YES!” now.

These universal truths of direct marketing work in print and online.

I'm portable. I offer you the flexibility to scale your team as needed.

It's not easy to sell the same thing over and over.  I've been privileged to work across many verticals in my career and I'm struck by how good ideas cross-pollinate. 

It's not unusual for my copywriter colleagues to discover my work, steal everything on my website, and then post on Facebook where the gold is hidden ...  

"If you want to witness brilliance, go to Josh's website and read every single word of every single page. Then save the pages to your computer and repeat the exercise again next week. Then the week after. Continue doing this week after week. In just a few months of this routine, you'll have gained more copywriting insight than sitting down with Gene Schwartz himself.  That Josh dude is a monster. And there's a ton you can pick up from his samples on his website." --K.G. 

No secret.  Hard work. I started my copywriting career when mailboxes were bursting with brilliant sales letters by the best freelance copywriters in the world.

I would climb into the dumpster behind my post office, drag home garbage bags of direct mail, and study how the great copywriters and designers teamed up to craft their elaborate mail packages.

Almost everything you see today on the web found an earlier form in print.

For large, easily definable projects where I go off and do my thing, we can establish a set fee--half up front.  

If, however, you want to throw a dozen of your most challenging conversion headaches at me, some clients have found it more convenient to pay me monthly so I thoroughly understand their business and can then tackle problems as they arise.

I'm easy and flexible.

Got a different plan in mind that works for you and your accounting department?  Let's chat. 

I can. I will work with your in-house design team, if you have one, or partner with the rock star, freelance, direct response graphic designers. I'm a creative Stop-and-Shop.

A direct mail copywriter is a professional writer who specializes in crafting persuasive marketing materials designed to be sent directly to a target audience through the mail. The goal is to generate a response—usually a sale, a donation, a subscription, or a lead.

Unlike general advertising copywriters, direct mail copywriters are response-driven. That means they write with a specific action in mind and measure success by how many people take that action.

What a Direct Mail Copywriter Writes:

Sales letters (the long-form kind that comes in an envelope)

  • Postcards
  • Self-mailers
  • Catalog copy
  • Insert mailers and envelope teasers
  • Response devices (order forms, reply cards)
  • Follow-up sequences

What Makes This Role Different:

Measurement: Every campaign has a clear ROI. You know how well it worked by the response rate.

  • Testing: Small changes (like a headline or call to action) are tested to see what improves results.
  • List targeting: The message must match the audience, often segmented by past behavior, income, geography, etc.
  • Offers: Direct mail copywriters understand how to structure and position irresistible offers.

Industries That Use Direct Mail Copywriters:

Insurance

  • Health and wellness
  • Financial services
  • Publishing and subscriptions
  • Nonprofits and fundraising
  • Membership and affinity programs
  • Consumer products (especially high-ticket or recurring offers)

In short, a direct mail copywriter doesn’t just write to sound good—they write to get results in the mailbox.

Turns out my old school copywriting skills are not only transferable to the digital world, but give me a perspective (and an edge) that is hard to replicate -- thank goodess!  As a result I hear from ...

  • Super smart founders, entrepreneurs, artists, mad scientists ... with brilliant ideas who ask me to help put their feverish ideas on paper and articulate their messaging -- clearly and compellingly.
  • Savvy performance marketers who know testing fresh creative from the best copywriters in the world is the fastest way to get big, historic wins.
  • Agencies and printer's (with In-house agencies) often ask me to fill in when they look around and realize they have gaps in their skill set.

 

"I swim in your wake."

For the BRILLIANT VISIONARY in you

FOR THE STARTUP FOUNDER IN YOU

FOR THE BOOK PUBLISHER IN YOU

FOR THE CANCER RESEARCHER IN YOU

FOR THE AUDIENCE DEVELOPER IN YOU

FOR THE SCREENWRITER IN YOU

make Contact